Currently Reading: Caste by Isabel Wilkerson
Showing posts with label 2008. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2008. Show all posts
Monday, September 10, 2012
The Secret Scripture
After completing this novel, I have decided that Sebastian Barry is one of my very favorite novelists - and I have only read two of his books. It is his rich and detailed writing style that I love - and his ability to connect his images to a story and to characters that I connect with on an emotional level.
The narrative is split between two characters - 100 year old Roseanne is an inmate at an asylum, and has been for many many decades. She's not clear why she has been committed to the asylum for all of these years, but she recounts her past as she remembers it in her journal, which serves as half of the narrative. Her doctor, Dr. Greene recounts the other half of the narrative in his medical log. He too does not understand why Roseanne has been an inmate and he is drawn to unearthing her past just as he avoids his own.
The Secret Scripture is a novel about memory and the past - as my favorite Irish novels seem to be. But it is also a beautiful story about loyalty, loss, and the tricky line between independence and isolation. And through this, Barry creates fantastic images. I can still picture the burning rat, and Roseanne's mother's clock, because they were described so richly and connected scenes that evoked very strong emotions. The hammers and the feathers --I can still see them falling.
Simply put, I really enjoyed this book. The imagery was so compelling because it was connected to a moving mystery told by two engaging and complex characters. I loved both the story being told by Roseanne, and the story that lay underneath as revealed by Dr. Greene - both the mysteries and the answers. In my opinion, it surpassed The White Tiger, which won this year.
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
The Clothes on Their Backs
I absolutely loved this book, in large part because I was able to identify with the main character and see echoes of my family's history in the characters. I felt that I understood their emotional responses and motives for their actions. However, even though I really connected with the story, I can see why it didn't ultimately win the Booker (being beat out by The White Tiger)
Vivien is the only child of Ervin and Berta Kovaks, Hungarian Jews who moved to London in the late 1930s as the extreme persecution was beginning. Once in London, Ervin chooses to keep his head down and assimilate - never going out, never making friends, never traveling - and as a result, Vivien grows up with almost no understanding of the country her parents came from, their religion, culture, language, or history. This set up resonated with me as a great-granddaughter of Eastern European immigrants to America, in a family that until very recently did not even know their former religion, language, or even the name of the village they came from. Perhaps my great-grandparents' attitudes were similar to Ervin Kovaks'.
But Vivien has an uncle Sandor, who came to London years after her parents did, and lived through the horrors of the labor camps during World War Two. Sandor and Ervin do not get along, and are in many ways opposite takes on life as an immigrant - one fading into a half-life to avoid detection and the other flamboyantly living life, and disregarding authority. Following a personal tragedy, Vivien defies her father and forges a relationship with her uncle, and in the process learns about her family history and her father's past. Throughout Vivien's story is a theme of the power of clothes: the transforming power of a new dress, the memories a pair of shoes can elicit, the class status associated with various types of clothes. And although this theme is pervasive throughout the novel, it never becomes overbearing or trite.
And as much as I connected with the story, I agree that it doesn't have the depth and fantastic language that the White Tiger had, and I'm sure not everyone connected with it as I did. So I'll concede this one to the Booker committee.
Monday, July 25, 2011
The White Tiger
This weekend I finished The White Tiger. I found this to be an engaging and interesting read, but it took me a little bit of contemplation to decide whether this novel seemed worthy of a Man Booker Prize. However, I found myself recommending the book to others before completely sorting out my feelings about it, so that strongly indicates that I enjoyed it.
The most compelling aspect of this story, about an Indian boy (Balram) who grows up in poverty and claws his way out, is the contemplation of what it means to be free versus what it means to be trapped. Balram discusses freedom frequently in this novel, and believes himself to be a free person after making the life-altering decision to murder his employer. This is a story of the many ways a person can be trapped or free, and what sacrifices and humiliations a person can endure to move from caged to free.
Adiga, through Balram, describes dilemma of the caged/free dichotomy most clearly though use of the metaphor of the "Rooster Coop" - a pile of cages in which chickens and roosters are packed waiting for slaughter:
"On the wooden desk above this coop sits a grinning young butcher, showing off the flesh and organs of a recently chopped-up chicken, still oleaginous with a coating of dark blood. The roosters in the coop smell the blood from above. They see the organs of their brothers lying around them. They know they're next. Yet they do not rebel. They do not try to get out of the coop."Balram and other impoverished low-caste Indians are stuck in the coop not because of a physical cage, but through bonds of family, duty, and dignity. In order to break out of his cage, he must sacrifice these bonds - through violating his sense of duty to his employer, sacrificing the health and lives of his entire extended family (who serve as a hostage against his loyalty to his employer), and his own sense of fairness and dignity in murdering his employer who has never directly harmed him and has, for the most part, treated him with more care and respect than any other person he knows. Balram's choices do not sit easily with me (and they seem very difficult for him), but I struggle to condemn him. This moral ambiguity, the impossibility of justice in Balram's India is what has stuck with me from this novel.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

